Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

choosing an MA Dissertation subject

barney_pig

Po-cha-na-quar-hip
Last year on here I was trying to get the cash together to fund my MA in Medieval studies, which I was able to start after receiving a grant from the Railway benevolent fund. The grant allowed me to start the first two modules and I'd hoped to find the rest as the year went by.
Now thanks to the kindness of a sponsor I am in the position to complete my MA and I am trying to decide on a dissertation subject.
my BA was somewhat let down by me choosing a poor subject for my dissertation, which had been based on an initial enthusiasm and a chance discovery of a small cache of documents in the county records office, which led me to assume that many more such documents would be accessable- they weren't.
At the moment I am considering studying "The Pre Crusade 'British' experience of Islam" which I think might provide me with plenty of scope for research; I think that this would mean looking at the three main 'British' societies- Anglo Saxon, Viking, and after 1066, Norman. and will focus upon three main spheres;
1. trade; either voluntary or otherwise- with an emphasis on the Great Viking slave market of Dublin, through which many British and Irish people made their unwilling aquaintance with the Caliphate either in North africa or Muslim Spain.
2. Conflict;
a. Irish Viking Raids on Spain,
b. The Norman war machine in which anglo norman militares might find themselves, through obligations of feof or through thirst for adventure and land, fighting Islam's armies in southern Italy, Sicily, or Spain.
c. The Anglo Saxon Diaspora- after 1066 there was an exodus of the surviving Anglo Saxon nobility, who became the bulk of the Varangian Guard ( a possible contributing factor in the distrust and frosty relationship between the frankish and Norman crusaders and the Byzantine armed forces?)
3. Pilgrimage: the medieval craze for physical pilgrimage does not flower till later, but individuals are travelling to the holy land throughout this period.


my main problem will be having had the idea how do I find the evidence to back it up? And what do does one do when the evidence does not turn up?
 
No idea how an MA differs but when I did my BA dissertation I tried to find a subject that I could be enthusiastic about, enough to do the work, and one which could provide enough academic study, both book study and primary and secondary research. I went through a few topic titles with my tutor until I found one that matched those criteria.
 
This is one of those subjects where it's hard to give anything but general advice, but what worked for me with my Masters was to do a lit search on the half dozen subjects I narrowed myself down to. See what had been previously published, and by whom.

if you have access to ATHENS it's fairly easy to pull off if you're prepared to put in a couple of weeks of wading through abstracts, following citation chains and being ruthless in screening out anything that doesn't apply. This at least gives you a basis for choosing your specific dissertation topic in an informed manner, and means you go into it knowing the rough "lay of the land" wrt to the literature.
 
Good luck with it. I've got to choose mine next year (doing it part time) and I've started thinking about topics, but keep on changing my mind.

Ethos could be a useful resource to see what others have done. It's a bank of PhD thesis, not all are available to download though http://ethos.bl.uk/Home.do
 
Don't forget

2. d. Slave raids on the south British coast.

But are you perhaps casting your net a little wide for a MA? Perhaps you might narrow it down?
 
You need to be genuinely interested in it. It's your chance to delve deeply into a topic for 3 or 4 months, make the most of it.

Turn a topic area into a specific question.

Make sure there are resources available to draw from.

Take your tutor's advice, unless s/he's a twat (in which case get a different tutor)
 
IME, keep it narrow. My MA dissertation was on the abolition of slavery in the Gold Coast. I think I had about 20,000 words to play with and needed them, even though there wasn't an awful lot of primary source material to deal with (for some reason an awful lot of the original letters to/from missionary societies were written in the worlds worst handwriting - I say this as a former medievalist who managed to negotiate their way through 13th century provencal script without the same degree of bother for an earlier degree) I needed every single word for quite a narrow topic. As regards availability of primary material - the Islam angle will make it easier, although skewed towards Islamic perceptions of the British; you'll need to counter that. Definitely get digging through previous PhD theses for their sources. And, as has been said before, don't get TOO distracted; but also, this may well throw up a topic that has better (more accessible, more numerous, more interesting) sources to work with. So don't get hung up on your topic/tack too early on in the game. Enjoy - sounds like a great subject area to play with!
 
I'd suggest making sure there's lots of available literature on your specific interest/ make sure it's something you're really interested in to make the reading less of a chore and avoid going off on tangents. Probably not relevant to your area of study but clearing ethical approval is also a big consideration too. Don't pick something you can't evidence, it will become a real struggle.
 
I did a history masters dissertation last year. The advice we were given was to check out the sources before going to far with any topic. One tutor suggested finding an archive, then picking the topic.. I didn't go that far but I did make sure of sources, and modified my research question as a result of initial investigations.

The other advice we got was that most people pick too broad a topic, or too general a question - so should narrow the focus as much as possible. Again - I had to cut what I wanted to do down. The book 'Succeeding with your Master's Dissertaion' by John Biggam is good to read - even if it does bang on about e-learning the whole time.
 
Might be a good idea to check what sort of primary sources are out there for the particular topics you're interested in, and how easy (or difficult) it might be to access them. Oh, and I just see that Hollis has posted the same thing.

I agree with Nick, eh I mean Hollis.
 
Just to third this. I agree with Random that it is the most important advice. Being overambitious was to the detriment of my MA dissertation, a mistake I appear to be currently repeating with my PhD :facepalm:

tbh, a good dissertation tutor would tell you to rewrite a broad, unfocussed diss topic.
 
tbh, a good dissertation tutor would tell you to rewrite a broad, unfocussed diss topic.

But what % of dissertation supervisors in any given institution are 'good'?

As in, accessible, give a shit about masters students, make time for supervisions, are half-competent in the specific field of someone's research and / or methodology, can be arsed to listen, are willing to engage (as opposed to instruct), etc, etc.

I'd hazard a - generous - 30-40%. Within my institute.

A couple of senior academics within my institute would hazard closer to 10-20%.
 
True, but telling you to rewrite your dissertation question is such a simple, standard response that it's an easy box-tick indicating engagement for a generally disengaged academic.
 
thanks for your comments, I am thinking of narrowing things down, whether looking at pilgrimage, the viking slave trade or the post 1066 anglo saxon diaspora. I will talk to my lecturers for advise.
 
Back
Top Bottom